Unlike many states, New York has no comprehensive bad faith insurance statute. Instead, bad faith claims are governed entirely by common law, creating both limitations and unique legal opportunities for policyholders. If your insurance company has wrongfully denied, delayed, or undervalued your claim, you may pursue a bad faith claim based on the insurer’s breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. Attorney Michael A. Siddons represents New York policyholders in bad faith disputes, navigating these complex legal rules to maximize your recovery.
Has your insurance claim been wrongfully denied? Call (610) 255-7500 today for a free consultation. Contact us online
New York’s Lack of Statutory Bad Faith Law
New York is distinctive among major states in having no comprehensive bad faith insurance statute. Proposed legislation has been pending for years without enactment. This absence of statutory law means that bad faith claims in New York depend entirely on the common law duty of good faith and fair dealing between contracting parties.
The lack of statutory law creates both challenges and opportunities. On one hand, New York courts have not developed as extensive a body of case law regarding bad faith as states with statutory frameworks. On the other hand, common law claims can be flexible, and an experienced attorney can craft arguments that adapt to the specific facts of your case.
First-Party Claims: Limited to Breach of Contract
New York’s approach to first-party bad faith claims is notably restrictive. Courts have held that when an insured sues their own insurer for wrongful denial of benefits, the claim is fundamentally a contract dispute—a claim for breach of the insurance policy itself.
This means that in first-party bad faith claims, you cannot recover damages beyond those available for ordinary breach of contract. You recover the policy benefits wrongfully withheld, plus interest, but you generally cannot recover punitive damages, attorney’s fees as damages, or other consequential damages even if the insurer’s conduct was egregious.
This limitation significantly restricts the incentive for insurers to act fairly in New York. Consulting with an experienced attorney is critical to ensuring your claim is framed correctly and that all available remedies under the breach of contract framework are pursued.
Third-Party Claims: The Gross Disregard Standard
Third-party bad faith claims—claims arising when an insurer covering the responsible party fails to settle a claim within policy limits—are treated differently in New York. These claims must meet the “gross disregard” standard articulated in Pavia v. State Farm Insurance Co. (1993).
The Pavia Gross Disregard Test
Under Pavia, an insurer is liable for bad faith when its conduct demonstrates a “gross disregard” of the insured’s interests. This standard is more restrictive than the “reasonableness” standards used in many other states. Gross disregard suggests something approaching reckless indifference to the policyholder’s interests, not merely unreasonable conduct.
This high threshold means third-party claimants in New York face a challenging burden. Examples of conduct that might meet the gross disregard standard include: an insurer with actual knowledge that a claim is within policy limits refuses to settle; an insurer deliberately ignores evidence clearly establishing liability; or an insurer employs tactics designed to pressure an insured into accepting an unreasonably low settlement.
N.Y. Insurance Law § 2601: No Private Right of Action
New York Insurance Law § 2601 prohibits unfair and deceptive practices in insurance transactions. However, courts have held that this statute does not create a private right of action for policyholders. You cannot directly sue under § 2601; instead, you must rely on common law bad faith claims. The statute may be relevant as evidence of bad faith in a common law claim, but it does not provide an independent basis for recovery.
General Business Law § 349: Limited Applicability
General Business Law § 349 prohibits deceptive practices and consumer fraud, and it does create a private right of action. Some policyholders have attempted to pursue insurance bad faith claims under § 349. However, courts have applied § 349 narrowly in the insurance context, and it is not a reliable primary basis for pursuing insurance bad faith claims. If your claim involves particularly egregious misrepresentation beyond typical insurance disputes, a § 349 claim might be possible as a supplement.
Statute of Limitations
Bad faith claims in New York are subject to a six-year statute of limitations, which applies to contract-based claims. This period typically runs from the date the insurer breaches its obligations. If the insurer’s improper conduct is ongoing, the statute may be continuously renewed.
Key New York Case Law
Pavia v. State Farm Insurance Co., 82 N.Y.2d 445 (1993): This seminal case established the gross disregard standard for third-party bad faith claims. The court held that an insurer’s conduct must demonstrate a “gross disregard” of the insured’s interests—a standard higher than ordinary negligence. Pavia remains the leading authority on third-party bad faith in New York.
Pending Legislation and Future Changes
Legislation has been proposed in New York to establish a comprehensive bad faith insurance statute similar to frameworks in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Maryland. These bills would expand remedies available to policyholders and provide clearer standards for insurer conduct. However, the insurance industry has resisted, and bills have not been enacted despite multiple attempts. An attorney experienced in New York insurance law will monitor developments that may affect your claim.
Why Experienced Counsel is Critical in New York
The complexity of New York’s common law framework, combined with the absence of statutory protection, makes it essential to retain an attorney who specializes in New York insurance law. An experienced attorney understands:
- How to frame claims to maximize available remedies under the breach of contract framework
- The distinction between first-party and third-party claims and the different standards that apply
- How to develop evidence that meets the demanding gross disregard standard
- Alternative theories of recovery (§ 349, § 2601 as evidence) that might supplement a bad faith claim
- Negotiation strategies that account for New York’s restrictive legal standards
What Constitutes Bad Faith in New York
Under New York common law, bad faith requires a breach of the implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing. In first-party claims, this typically means wrongful denial of benefits that are clearly covered, or unreasonable delay. In third-party claims, examples of gross disregard include:
- Refusing to settle a claim clearly within policy limits despite a reasonable demand
- Ignoring evidence clearly establishing liability
- Deliberately employing dilatory tactics to pressure unreasonable settlement
- Failing to communicate with the insured about settlement negotiations affecting their liability
Frequently Asked Questions About New York Bad Faith Claims
Why doesn’t New York have a bad faith insurance statute?
The insurance industry has opposed such legislation. While bills have been proposed repeatedly, they have not been enacted, leaving New York policyholders with fewer statutory protections than neighboring states.
What is the difference between first-party and third-party claims in New York?
A first-party claim is against your own insurer and is limited to contract remedies. A third-party claim is against the insurer covering the responsible party and must meet the gross disregard standard, but may offer more recovery potential.
What is the “gross disregard” standard?
Gross disregard means reckless indifference to the policyholder’s interests—a standard higher than ordinary negligence. You must demonstrate not just unreasonable conduct, but conduct with knowledge of wrongfulness or reckless disregard for your interests.
Can I recover punitive damages in a New York bad faith claim?
In first-party claims, no. In third-party claims that meet the gross disregard standard, punitive damages may be available but are applied sparingly by New York courts.
How long do I have to bring a bad faith claim in New York?
Six years from the date the insurer breaches its obligations. Consult an attorney promptly to preserve your rights.
Contact Michael A. Siddons for Your New York Bad Faith Claim
New York’s common law bad faith framework is complex and restrictive, making experienced counsel essential. Michael A. Siddons has deep knowledge of New York insurance law and represents policyholders throughout the state.
Call (610) 255-7500 or contact us online to discuss your claim today.
By Insurer: State Farm | Allstate | GEICO | Progressive
By State: Overview | Pennsylvania | New Jersey | Maryland
← Back to Bad Faith Insurance Overview
