New Jersey enacted the Insurance Fair Conduct Act in 2021, effective January 1, 2022, creating the first comprehensive statutory bad faith framework in the state. This landmark legislation specifically addresses bad faith conduct in uninsured motorist (UM) and underinsured motorist (UIM) claims. If your insurance company has wrongfully denied, delayed, or undervalued your UM/UIM claim, you have legal recourse under this new law. Attorney Michael A. Siddons represents New Jersey policyholders whose insurers have violated the Insurance Fair Conduct Act, securing compensation for wrongful denials and inadequate settlement offers.
Has your UM/UIM claim been wrongfully denied? Call (610) 255-7500 today for a free consultation with Michael A. Siddons. Contact us online
The Insurance Fair Conduct Act: New Jersey’s Statutory Framework
The Insurance Fair Conduct Act, codified at N.J.S.A. 17:29BB-1 et seq., represents a significant expansion of rights for New Jersey policyholders. Prior to this statute, New Jersey courts recognized bad faith claims primarily through common law, with relatively limited remedies. The 2021 legislation changed this landscape fundamentally.
The Act establishes that an insurer shall not engage in unfair or deceptive conduct in the settlement of UM/UIM claims, including: misrepresenting facts related to the claim; unreasonably refusing to pay a reasonable settlement demand; failing to acknowledge receipt of communications; failing to act promptly in processing the claim; failing to explain the denial of a claim; or making offers that are substantially below what a reasonable insurer would offer under similar circumstances.
Scope: Limited to UM/UIM Claims
It is crucial to understand that the Insurance Fair Conduct Act applies specifically to uninsured motorist and underinsured motorist coverage. The statute does not extend to other first-party claims, such as homeowners insurance claims, auto collision coverage, or other property damage claims. For non-UM/UIM bad faith claims in New Jersey, plaintiffs continue to rely on common law bad faith principles, which provide narrower remedies.
However, for those with UM/UIM coverage, the Act provides unprecedented statutory protections that place the burden of proving fair conduct on the insurer.
Damages Under the Insurance Fair Conduct Act
One critical limitation of the Act is that damages are capped at three times the UM/UIM coverage limit. This means if your policy provides $100,000 in UM/UIM coverage, the maximum total recovery (including policy benefits, damages, interest, and attorney’s fees) is $300,000.
Within this cap, the Act allows recovery for:
Policy Benefits
First, you recover the full amount of UM/UIM benefits owed under your policy.
Compensatory Damages
You may recover damages for losses resulting from the insurer’s improper conduct, such as costs incurred in pursuing the claim, lost income, medical expenses, or emotional distress.
Pre-Judgment and Post-Judgment Interest
The Act provides for recovery of pre-judgment interest on unpaid benefits at New Jersey’s statutory rate, as well as post-judgment interest from the date judgment is entered until payment.
Attorney’s Fees and Costs
A successful claimant may recover reasonable attorney’s fees and litigation costs incurred in prosecuting the bad faith claim.
Important Limitation: No Punitive Damages
Unlike Pennsylvania and some other states, the Insurance Fair Conduct Act does not provide for punitive damages. The remedies are limited to compensatory damages, interest, and attorney’s fees within the statutory cap.
Statute of Limitations
The Insurance Fair Conduct Act establishes a six-year statute of limitations for claims brought under the statute. This period runs from the date of the violation—typically when the insurer first fails to comply with the Act’s requirements. Given that the Act is relatively new and courts continue to interpret its provisions, consulting with an attorney promptly is critical.
Unresolved Legal Issues
As of now, several important questions about the Insurance Fair Conduct Act remain unresolved as courts develop case law:
Retroactivity
Does the Act apply to claims arising from accidents that occurred before January 1, 2022, but where the bad faith conduct occurred after the Act’s effective date? Courts have not yet fully addressed this question.
Burden of Proof
While the statutory language suggests the insurer must demonstrate compliance with the Act’s standards, some questions remain about the precise allocation of burden during discovery and at trial.
Severability and Scope
If courts find certain provisions of the Act unconstitutional or unenforceable, which remedies would remain available? The interaction between the statutory remedies and common law claims is still being defined through litigation.
What Constitutes Unfair or Deceptive Conduct Under the Act
The Insurance Fair Conduct Act identifies several specific types of conduct that constitute violations:
- Misrepresenting facts: Providing false information about coverage, the claim, or applicable policy terms.
- Unreasonable refusal: Refusing to pay a settlement demand that is reasonable given the facts and the coverage limit.
- Failure to acknowledge: Not acknowledging receipt of communications from the policyholder or claimant.
- Failure to process promptly: Unreasonably delaying investigation, evaluation, or payment of the claim.
- Failure to explain denials: Not clearly communicating the reason for denying or reducing the benefit amount.
- Inadequate settlement offers: Making offers that are substantially below reasonable value under similar circumstances.
Frequently Asked Questions About New Jersey Bad Faith Claims
Does the Insurance Fair Conduct Act apply to my homeowners or auto collision claim?
No. The Act applies only to uninsured motorist (UM) and underinsured motorist (UIM) claims. For other types of first-party claims, you may still pursue common law bad faith, but the remedies are more limited.
What is the three-times cap on damages?
Under the Act, total recovery is capped at three times the policy’s UM/UIM coverage limit. If your policy limit is $100,000, the maximum total recovery is $300,000, including all policy benefits, compensatory damages, interest, and attorney’s fees.
Can I recover punitive damages under the Insurance Fair Conduct Act?
No. The Act does not provide for punitive damages. Recovery is limited to compensatory damages within the three-times cap, interest, and attorney’s fees.
How long do I have to bring a claim under the Insurance Fair Conduct Act?
You have six years from the date of the violation. However, questions about retroactivity and tolling are still being litigated, so consult an attorney promptly.
Do I need an attorney to pursue a claim under the Act?
While you can pursue your claim yourself, the Act is complex and insurers are well-resourced. An experienced attorney understands how to develop evidence and navigate procedural requirements. Many attorneys, including our firm, represent clients on a contingency basis—you pay no fees unless we recover for you.
Contact Michael A. Siddons for Your New Jersey Bad Faith Claim
New Jersey’s Insurance Fair Conduct Act has created unprecedented opportunities for policyholders to hold their insurers accountable. If your insurer has acted unfairly in handling your UM/UIM claim, you deserve an advocate who understands this new law.
Call (610) 255-7500 or contact us online to discuss your claim today.
By Insurer: State Farm | Allstate | GEICO | Progressive
By State: Overview | Pennsylvania | Maryland | New York
← Back to Bad Faith Insurance Overview
